Are you trying to decide between a two-way radio and a walkie-talkie, but you need to know the difference? Many people think these two devices are identical, but several key differences exist.
Two-way radios are more sophisticated, cover a more extended range, have emergency features, and have more complex capabilities. Many businesses, hospitals, and universities use two-way radios. The communication is more transparent, and the sound quality is a step above the walkie-talkie.
Two-way radios are more robust and have more advanced features. Reading this article will help you learn more about the differences between two-way radios and walkie-talkies.
What Are the Differences Between Two-Way Radio and Walkie-Talkie?
The terms walkie-talkie and two-way radio are often used interchangeably. Walkie-talkies and two-way radios are very similar but also have many differences. Both operate on radio waves. They can both send and receive radio transmissions. The main differences between the two include:
- Cost
- Range
- Portability
- Capabilities
- Applications
- Sound Quality
- Emergency features
- Available frequencies
Walkie-talkies are less complex compared to two-way radios. Walkie-talkies are known as kid’s toys but are also used as communication devices. The differences between a walkie-talkie and a two-way radio are subtle but essential. The following explains some of the differences between the two:
Portability
Walkie-talkies can be taken almost anywhere and are easy to transport. However, two-way radios may be stationary like an old-school telephone and may need to be plugged in. You can purchase cheaper two-way radios that take batteries, but you would be sacrificing the quality of a more formidable device. Walkie-talkies make it possible to communicate as you are walking around (get it? “walkie-talkie!”)
Capabilities
Two-way radios are more sophisticated due to their ability to communicate with several channels and a higher user capacity. With a walkie-talkie, you push a button to turn it on, and it only transmits one radio on the channel. There are two types of walkie-talkies: long-range and short-range, and they only work in simplex mode, which means only one person at a time can talk.
Simplex also means that the radio has only one frequency. Two-way radios are more complex, as there are two kinds: full and half duplex. The half-duplex only receives signals but cannot go in both directions, while the full duplex can send and receive signals simultaneously. Simplex, full duplex, and half duplex indicate how radios use their allocated frequencies. Some of the unique features of two-way radio:
- NOAA weather alerts
- Sound tracker system
- Text-to-speech conversion
- Antennae warning indicator
Walkie-talkies do not require towers or electricity to operate, and neither do two-way radios. However, even though walkie-talkies are considered two-way radios, not all two-way radios can be regarded as walkie-talkies. Walkie-talkies only come with set channels you cannot change, and they have a fixed antenna and are also susceptible to water damage.
Emergency Features
Two-way radios also have unique features. They may have an emergency alert button you can press to call for help if there is an emergency. The other features may have some peculiar names. The Lone Worker is a feature that triggers an alert if the user does not check in on time. It is good when someone works alone; if the person does not respond, this feature can facilitate sending for help.
The man-down feature can help the person operate in hazardous or elevated areas. It can sense a lack of movement over a long period, as the person may have fallen, and prompt facilitation of acquiring help is necessary. For example, someone working in construction may have fallen or collapsed, and a two-way radio can trigger an alert for help.
The lost connection feature monitors radio connection. If the person strays too far or drops out, this feature helps to bring them back in range. In other words, it maintains the link when you are in range and remedies the connection when you are out of range. When the operator ensures you are back where you need to be, the radio signals to establish that the connection is restored.
Learn more about Best Emergency Radios & What NOAA Weather Radio?
These emergency features can help you stay safe in situations in which you are in a remote area. The emergency alert button permits immediate communication between individuals or groups. It is a convenient feature when you only have seconds to make that call. Walkie-talkies do not have these features.
Cost
Walkie-talkies are generally cheaper than two-way radios. However, you will likely need several walkie-talkies if you want others to join the conversation, which can get expensive depending on the number of people involved. Since two-way radios have better technical features, they are more expensive. They require licenses to use it, but you can use the device uninterrupted.
A professional two-way radio will cost more; the more expensive two-way radios typically have a higher output. Overall, the cost will depend on the brand of radio you choose. The more professional walkie-talkies tend to be pricier than their less sophisticated versions.
Sound Quality
Two-way radios have better sound quality, picking up clearer, sharper signals than walkie-talkies. When you use a walkie-talkie, interference, like static, can drive you crazy. The equipment that comes with the two-way radio is also superior to the walkie-talkie:
- Display
- Buttons
- Speaker
- Antennae
- Microphone
Two-way radios connect to external antennas to broaden the range. Most two-way radios also have input jacks to connect to the wall or other outlets. Some come with batteries, like lithium-ion batteries.
Range
Walkie-talkies come with smaller antennae; their range is not as impressive. It cannot pick up with longer distances, and you will not be able to communicate over an extended range. Two-way radio range often falls between 150MHz to 900MHz. Long-range radios can work for about 20 to 30 miles. The factors that affect the range are signal include:
- Weather
- Antennae
- Signal type
- Signal strength
- Obstructions
The above can be obstacles that can make a big difference in the range of the two-way radio you are using. Walkie-talkies may have a limited range, but a short-range walkie-talkie can be effective if you are not attempting to communicate over a wide range. Walkie-talkies are fine if you are not planning on communicating past 500 to 1000 yards, depending on how powerful the device is. These radios are more reasonably priced.
Learn about What is an EPIRB?, PLB vs. Satellite Messenge & EPIRB vs. PLB to use on a boat.
Applications
Walkie-talkies are for those who want to communicate over short distances. They are ideal for outdoor sports, like hiking or kayaking. They are perfect for an outdoor adventure because they allow you to communicate with others with poor reception or coverage. Walkie-talkies are also often used in the military to convey messages and commands.
Two-way radios are excellent for many applications:
- Police
- Hotels
- Hospitals
- Businesses
- Universities
They are also used by emergency services, retail shopping centers, and sat stadium events. Two-way communication may be better for these instances when you need more precise communication over longer distances, as you can communicate better from a permanent place. Two-way radios are professional radios that are stronger and may have more advanced features.
Available Frequencies
The majority of two-way radios are either high-frequency or ultra-high frequency. High frequency means that it operates somewhere between 30 to 299 MHz. Some other common uses for VHFs include Digital Audio Broadcasting, FM radio, and television broadcasting. Ultra-high frequencies have radio frequencies that operate between 300 Megahertz to 3,000 Megahertz.
UHF-FM has a typical range of less than 50 miles. Fire, public safety, and cell phones use ultra-high radio frequencies. UHF waves are also common in ship and aircraft navigation systems. This broadcast range is shorter and can produce higher waves than VHF. Ultra-high radio frequencies are so powerful that they can transmit through building walls. Many walkie-talkies are license-free radio applications that utilize frequencies between 462.5625 MHz and 462.7250 MHz.
Read, Shortwave Radio Station Frequencies, What Is a VHF Marine Radio? & VHF vs UHF.
More About Walkie-Talkie Frequencies
Modern walkie-talkies use Family Radio Service, which utilizes 22 channels. However, you need a license to use General Mobile Radio Service. If you use this service, you must adhere to the rules of the Federal Communications Commission. PMR446 is for personal use walkie talkies. There is no need for a license to use this frequency. The range is 446.0 to 446.2 MHz. These walkie-talkies are not used in the United States or Canada. The United States uses the Family Radio Service system.
What Are Examples of Walkie-Talkies?
Walkie-talkies are simpler devices, but they sure have come a long way. They work by allowing you to communicate within a specific mile range. They have modern features and can be suitable for kids not old enough for smartphones, but you want to know where they are during the day. They can even work as baby monitors when they have a voice activation feature and hands-free function.
The following includes examples of walkie-talkies:
Wishhouse Rechargeable Walkie-Talkie for Kids
The range on these colorful walkie-talkies is up to 20 miles. They are great for maintaining contact with your kids when they go on a bike ride or shoot hoops at the local park. There is also a built-in flashlight for when the day turns to evening. With this device, you can set up privacy channels for your family.
Motorola Talkabout T800
The range on this device is about 35 miles, which is impeccable. It connects to your smartphone app and boasts a long battery life. Weather alerts come from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, and you can also send messages over radio frequencies.
What Are Examples of Two-Way Radios?
Businesses and emergency services often use two-way radios. They have more complex features and can be lifesavers in certain situations. They are also ideal when your cell phone is not receiving adequate service. The following includes examples of two-way radios:
BaoFeng BF F8HP
This is a General Mobile Radio Service radio requiring a license to operate. You need to know the local rules and laws to be able to operate it properly. It has an incredible range and a plethora of settings and features.
Motorola T100
These two-way radios can receive signals from Family Radio Service and General Mobile Radio Service operators. They have 22 channels with excellent sound quality. These two-way radios are more affordable than most.
Brief History of The Walkie Talkie
The first portable walkie-talkie was invented in 1937 by Donald Lewis Hings. It was created for use in the military, as it helped pilots and soldiers communicate. They were also utilized for tank units and field artillery. After the war, they were used for public safety. The early walkie-talkies looked like a big box with an antenna, microphone, and speaker. It was not like the compact models we see today.
Walkie-talkies are now smaller and more convenient. Some can be made smaller than a deck of cards, and other walkie-talkies allow you to attach microphones and speakers. They are less sophisticated than two-way radios, but they serve their purpose. They have many uses and are often used in conjunction with outdoor activities. Kids can use them, as the Fisher-Price™ walkie-talkie is a popular toy.
Brief History of The Two-Way Radio
The original two-way radio was created in 1923 by Frederick William Downie, who was the Chief Constable of the Victorian Police in Australia. They were the first to use wireless communication. These devices were substantial and took up the whole backseat of the police car. However, two-way radios vastly improved police communication and helped them catch criminals more quickly and efficiently.
Two-way radios are now compact and convenient. They also have many more accessories, like batteries that are rechargeable, belt clips, and multi-charging units. They may also come with speaker mics and headsets. Two-way radios are helpful in many different industries. They have a more extended range than walkie-talkies and can benefit those who want to communicate over longer distances.
Conclusion
Two-way radios differ from walkie-talkies as they are more sophisticated and cover a more comprehensive range. Two way-radios also have better features and more outstanding capabilities. If you are looking for a device you can use outdoors when the phone service is spotty, a walkie-talkie will do fine. However, if you want a more complex device that can help save your life in an emergency, a two-way radio is what you need.
Sources:
Also Read, Previous Post about How Far Does a CB Radio Reach?
